Tackling Most cancers with Math | Math ∞ Weblog

The latest loss of life of Apple founder Steve Jobs from pancreatic most cancers on the younger age of fifty-six highlights the dismal progress within the Struggle on Most cancers, regardless of over $200 billion, over a million printed analysis papers, and the efforts of a whole lot of hundreds of extremely certified, exhausting working, dedicated researchers since 1971.

Steve Jobs inspiring graduation handle to Stanford College can be a poignant reminder of the ephemeral nature of phrases like “cured” and “curable” in most cancers analysis and therapy. Steve Jobs might properly have believed his uncommon type of pancreatic most cancers was “cured” or “curable” as he claimed his docs instructed him.

Steve Jobs loss of life additionally highlights the restricted advantages of right this moment’s extraordinarily highly effective computer systems and electronics in fields outdoors of computer systems and electronics. Regardless of the ceaselessly hyped promise of multi-Gigahertz and multi-core CPUs, these spectacular chips have not often translated into substantial progress in drugs, energy, propulsion, and different important areas.

One want solely contemplate the various tragic deaths from most cancers, the present rising vitality costs, and the seeming wars over dwindling provides of cheap oil and pure gasoline that plague the world right this moment. Steve Jobs and his crew at Apple have created many spectacular devices such because the iPhone and iPad, however they had been unable to take advantage of their laptop experience to defeat most cancers. Is there a greater manner? Can we harness the unused energy of right this moment’s computer systems to resolve these urgent issues?

The big energy of right this moment’s computer systems is ineffective with out ideas, arithmetic, and algorithms that use this energy to resolve actual issues.

There was spectacular progress in some areas together with video compression such because the H.264 and associated requirements utilized by YouTube, Skype and lots of different instruments, audio compression comparable to MP3, picture compression such because the broadly used JPEG normal, laptop generated photographs for motion pictures, tv, and laptop video games, the World Positioning System or GPS that tells folks the place they’re, and even speech recognition which is slowly discovering some sensible use regardless of many difficulties.

There may be at the moment a fad to develop and implement suggestion engines comparable to Netflix’s Cinematch system to advocate purchases to prospects utilizing superior statistical strategies.

At finest suggestion engines can improve gross sales by solely a tiny quantity, a number of p.c, and might by no means remedy crucial, trillion greenback market dimension, issues comparable to most cancers, the illnesses of outdated age, and vitality shortages. Improved video compression within the type of video conferencing instruments comparable to Skype might properly assist remedy the present vitality disaster. Video conferencing, nonetheless, can not substitute for many vitality wants. Different advances are wanted. As Steve Jobs loss of life exhibits, many main issues haven’t been solved in any respect.

This text discusses some ways in which math and computer systems is perhaps used to develop a treatment for most cancers. It’s a follow-on article to the earlier article Can Arithmetic Treatment Most cancers?

This text discusses ways in which arithmetic is perhaps used to establish and selectively destroy most cancers cells. It discusses a selected method and algorithm, “The Bathtub Mechanism,” that might be able to selectively kill cells with an irregular variety of chromosomes, a typical characteristic of many cancers, and presents a sketch of some methods this algorithm is perhaps carried out utilizing mobile and molecular constructing blocks that could be recognized to current day biology, avoiding the necessity to assemble nanorobots, one thing nonetheless far sooner or later.

All About Most cancers

The present prevailing principle of most cancers is the oncogene or “most cancers gene” principle. That is seen as a indisputable fact by many molecular biologists. Most cancers is now mentioned to be a whole lot, even hundreds of various illnesses. Whereas a medical physician or pathologist might establish one thing as “breast most cancers” or “pores and skin most cancers” or an analogous common class, at a molecular and genetic degree, “breast most cancers” is definitely many various illnesses.

It’s thought that most cancers is brought on by the buildup of many mutations of many various oncogenes and tumor suppressor genes that management advanced networks of proteins that direct the expansion, functioning, and differentiation of cells. In biology, differentiation refers back to the course of by which cells “differentiate” throughout progress into numerous specialised forms of cells comparable to neurons within the mind, blood cells, and pores and skin cells with totally different particular properties and capabilities.

One kind of breast most cancers might have genes A,B,C, and D mutated whereas one other has genes W, X, Y, and Z mutated. Not solely this, however the cancers are regarded as frequently mutating and evolving within the physique, growing immunity to chemotherapy medication for instance. Thus, there doesn’t appear to be a typical molecular goal that an anti-cancer drug can goal in the best way that penicillin or different antibiotics can kill a variety of various micro organism, for instance.

There could also be system degree options of most cancers cells that establish them. Conventional chemotherapy medication had been designed to kill dividing cells on the speculation that most cancers cells divide quickly. Nevertheless, wholesome cells divide additionally and conventional chemotherapy has very restricted advantages for many cancers. Solely surgical removing of a tumor earlier than it spreads — turns into metastatic in most cancers jargon — seems to have the ability to treatment most cancers utilizing the widespread sense definition of “treatment”. Whereas concentrating on cell division largely doesn’t work, concentrating on different system degree traits of most cancers may go.

It might be doable, with nice issue, to provide a small system of interacting medication that carry out a mathematical or logical calculation within the cell and selectively kill most cancers cells or possible most cancers cells whereas sparing regular cells. It’s right here that arithmetic could also be of use. To attain success within the close to future, the less complicated the arithmetic the higher. Even engineering a single molecule comparable to genetically engineered insulin for diabetics is a frightening job at current. So a system of even a number of molecules can be a considerable and tough enterprise.

The Selective Destruction of Cells with Irregular Numbers of Chromosomes

(NOTE: This part largely repeats the part with the identical title within the earlier article Can Arithmetic Treatment Most cancers? In case you are aware of the idea, chances are you’ll skip this part and bounce to the next part which discusses the best way to implement the tub mechanism.)

One widespread attribute of many cancers is an irregular variety of chromosomes, often called aneuploidy. That is usually an extra variety of chromosomes. A traditional wholesome human cell has forty-six (46) chromosomes. Most cancers cells usually have greater than forty-six chromosomes. This was found lengthy earlier than the fashionable genetic period.

One historic principle, now out of favor, is that the irregular variety of chromosomes causes most cancers. This principle is often credited to the German biologist Theodor Boveri. Essentially the most distinguished fashionable advocate of the position of aneuploidy and chromosomes in most cancers is the extraordinarily controversial researcher Peter Duesberg who has printed some articles on his theories in most cancers analysis journals and a well-liked article in Scientific American in 2007 (“Chromosomal Chaos and Most cancers”, Scientific American, Might, 2007).

Plenty of different researchers comparable to Angelika Amon at MIT have been investigating the position of chromosomes and aneuploidy in most cancers in recent times; references are given within the earlier article Can Arithmetic Treatment Most cancers?.

The irregular variety of chromosomes or the opposite chromosomal anomalies usually seen in a variety of cancers could also be a system-level attribute of most cancers that could possibly be focused regardless of the acute variation in gene-level mutations (part-level traits of most cancers).

Despite the fact that there are over one-million analysis papers on most cancers, it’s tough to get a transparent image of the position of aneuploidy in most cancers. Most fashionable most cancers analysis is performed inside the framework of the oncogene principle and an implicit assumption that the best way to treatment or deal with most cancers is to focus on both a protein generated by a most cancers gene or the gene straight.

Chromosomal anomalies, each irregular numbers of chromosomes and the rearrangements of chromosomes which might be widespread in lots of cancers, are often mentioned as an apart to the putative most cancers genes. This translocation of chromosome X mutated the important thing most cancers gene ABC, or the duplication of chromosome X resulted in two copies of the important thing most cancers gene ABC.

It could possibly be that killing most cancers cells with the improper variety of chromosomes would haven’t any impact on the illness. It will merely lead to a most cancers with the right variety of chromosomes within the surviving most cancers cells. It might sluggish the illness if the irregular variety of chromosomes is expounded to the malignancy of the most cancers cells. In the most effective case, it would treatment the illness, if the irregular variety of chromosomes is both the reason for most cancers, important to the malignant nature of the most cancers cells, or just all the time related to malginancy for another cause.

It might be doable to kill cells with an irregular variety of chromosomes utilizing a system of 5 molecules: a innocent precursor A, a supply catalyst S, a cell killer B, a drain catalyst D, and a neutralized cell killer C that the cell can safely digest or excrete.

The supply catalyst S is inactive till it bonds to a numerical or quantitative characteristic on the chromosomes such because the telomeres on the ends of the chromosomes or the centromeres on the middle. It turns into an lively catalyst S* when it bonds to the chromosomes. Then the activated catalyst S* catalyzes the conversion of a innocent precursor A right into a cell killer B. The activated catalyst S* has a most throughput. If the focus of the precusor A is excessive sufficient within the cells, the catalyst S* will add the cell killer to the cell at a charge proportional to the variety of chromosomes within the cell.

The cell killer B is comparatively innocent in low concentrations. It must construct as much as a excessive degree to kill the cell. To this point, this can occur in all cells. Nevertheless, if there’s a drain catalyst D that bonds to a numerical characteristic within the cell that’s the identical in each regular cells and irregular cells (most cancers cells) and turns into an lively drain catalyst D* that removes the cell killer B by changing it to the neutralized cell killer C, then the focus of B might be engineered to rise to deadly ranges solely in cells with too many chromosomes.
A ==>S*==> B
B ==>D*==> C

This method of medicine is sort of a bathtub with a number of operating taps, one for every chromosome, and a single drain. If there are too many taps, chromosomes, the water degree, the focus of the cell killer B, will rise and overflow the tub. If there are the best quantity, forty-six, or too few, lower than forty-six, taps, the drain can take away the water being added and the water degree by no means rises. The water degree stays virtually zero; the focus of the cell killer B is manner too low to hurt the cell.

One can kill cells with too few chromosomes (lower than forty-six) by swapping the roles of the drain and the supply. The drain catalyst bonds to the chromosomes. The supply catalyst bonds to the fixed numerical characteristic of the cells. Thus, if there are too few chromosomes, there should not sufficient activated drains to take away the cell killer B produced by the supply catalyst. The bath has one massive faucet and lots of small drains, one for every chromosome.

In precept, one might get rid of all cells with both too many or too few chromosomes by first treating the affected person with a system of medicine that kills cells with too many chromosomes after which a system of medicine that kills cells with too few chromosomes. Most cancers cells are ceaselessly reported to have too many chromosomes, however generally too few can be reported.

A computational system of this sort would now (2011) be simple to implement utilizing mechanical elements just like the gears and is derived utilized in conventional mechanical clocks, vacuum tubes and different conventional analog electronics elements, or an built-in circuit. The issue is that so simple as such a computational system is, this can be very difficult to implement utilizing our present capacity to engineer proteins and molecular organic techniques within the cell.

Tips on how to Implement the Bathtub Mechanism

The bath mechanism requires two options within the cell: a numerical or quantitative characteristic that’s proportional to the variety of chromosomes and a characteristic that’s fixed in all cells, each regular and cancerous. It’s generally reported that most cancers cells have irregular numbers of antigens on the membranes of the cells. Therefore, the tub mechanism might not require a characteristic that varies with the variety of chromosomes, however this text is about concentrating on irregular numbers of chromosomes moderately than antigens.

Some apparent options that most likely differ with the variety of chromosomes are the telomeres on the finish of the chromosomes and the centromeres on the middle of the chromosomes. These are each concerned in cell division. There needs to be concern that the supply or drain catalyst binding to the telomere or centromere might intervene with cell division. The bath mechanism should kill all of the most cancers cells and spare most or all the wholesome cells. It might be doable to make use of the telomeres or centromeres, however it could possibly be inconceivable.

A extra promising characteristic could also be among the non-coding sequences within the chromosome DNA, the so-called “junk DNA.” It’s at the moment thought that the overwhelming majority of DNA within the chromosome has no operate. On theoretical grounds, the writer finds this implausible as do many. Nevertheless, the genes that seem to code for the proteins within the physique appear to comprise just a few p.c of the DNA within the chromosomes. The remaining appears to do nothing. Sequences of non-coding DNA are utilized in DNA profiling, for instance. Relying on the precise operate of the junk DNA, if any, it could be doable to soundly bind a supply or drain catalyst to non-coding sequences that adjust in amount with the variety of chromosomes.

There are various molecular buildings within the chromosomes and related to the chromosomes. It appears possible, though not sure, that one can discover a numerical or quantitative characteristic that varies with the variety of chromosomes that could possibly be used. A extra major problem with the tub mechanism is the fixed characteristic that’s the identical in each wholesome cells and most cancers cells, particularly since most cancers cells are regarded as always mutating and altering. This can be a show-stopper.

Because the most cancers cells could also be mutating, it could be inconceivable to discover a fixed characteristic within the most cancers cells. The characteristic might disappear solely or change in dimension or quantity. There may be no less than one doable manner so as to add such a characteristic artificially to the cells, each wholesome and malignant.

Bacteriophage P2 using Transmission Electron Microscope

Bacteriophage P2 utilizing Transmission Electron Microscope

A bacteriophage is a sort of virus that attaches to the outside membrane of a cell and injects its genetic materials into the cell. The bacteriophage’s genetic materials then takes over the equipment of the cell and directs it to make extra bacteriophages. The bacteriophage consists of a protein sheath that appears one thing like a science fiction bug (see footage) with a number of arms that seize the floor of the cell and a polygonal chamber that carries the genetic materials.

3D Model of T4 Bacteriophage

3D Mannequin of T4 Bacteriophage

In precept, one might modify the genetic materials of the bacteriophage to create cells (the generally used E. Coli micro organism, for instance) that make not the virus, however the protein sheath with a payload of different proteins. These pseudo-bacteriophages would inject their protein payloads into cells as a substitute of the genetic materials of the naturally occurring bacteriophage. They’d not be infectious like a traditional virus.

If, and it is a massive if, one might modify the protein sheath so it will solely inject the protein payload right into a cell with out an inhibitor protein I that’s a part of the payload, one might inject a payload that contained a man-made fixed characteristic F and the inhibitors I into the cell. As soon as the brand new characteristic that the drain or supply catalysts would bind to was added to the cell, the pseudo-bacteriophages would cease injecting payloads into the cell as a result of it now additionally contained the inhibitors. Thus, a relentless variety of options could possibly be added to every cell, each wholesome and cancerous.

Math and Computer systems

This can be a simplified sketch of the tub mechanism, a primary idea. Many technical particulars and difficulties have been omitted to current the thought. Whereas it is perhaps doable to analysis and develop the tub mechanism solely empirically at a laboratory bench by huge trial and error, it needs to be doable to considerably speed up the event course of by simulating the molecular mechanisms utilizing right this moment’s highly effective computer systems. In observe, it will most likely require cautious tuning of the chemical response charges within the cell to provide the specified selective destruction of cells with irregular numbers of chromosomes or different options related to most cancers.

One shouldn’t count on the pc simulations to be excellent. They’d most likely be removed from excellent at first. Somewhat, using mathematical fashions and computer systems needs to be a part of an iterative course of through which the fashions and simulations are repeatedly in comparison with laboratory bench experiments and improved. The fundamental idea might also have to be modified iteratively as new knowledge is collected. This has been the standard course of in most real breakthroughs.


It might be doable to treatment or successfully deal with most cancers with a system of good medication that carry out a easy mathematical or logical calculation to selectively destroy most cancers cells or possible most cancers cells whereas sparing regular wholesome cells. These techniques of good medication might be able to establish system degree options of most cancers cells impartial of the complicated plethora of most cancers genes and tumor suppressor genes. The bath mechanism mentioned on this article is one doable instance of such a system of good medication. Arithmetic and computer systems can allow or enormously speed up the event of such techniques of good medication.

The writer means that most cancers researchers, enterprise leaders, and coverage makers ought to direct a major period of time and sources to the investigation of such techniques of good medication. This needs to be a diversified effort not specializing in anyone explicit method comparable to the tub mechanism. Whereas there needs to be some redundancy, there’s most likely no level in having dozens of competing analysis teams all making an attempt the identical primary method as appears to be the case with the present makes an attempt to use differential equations to modeling the expansion and unfold of most cancers, the main present instance of making use of arithmetic to most cancers analysis and therapy. A extra various effort that’s prepared and in a position to query extra assumptions is extra more likely to succeed based mostly on the historical past of scientific analysis and technological growth.

The profitable utility of arithmetic and computer systems to most cancers and biology requires knowledgeable working relationship based mostly on mutual respect between consultants in a number of fields: computer systems, arithmetic, physics, and conventional biology. The latest look of extraordinarily highly effective computer systems presages a sea change in biology and lots of different fields the place computer systems and arithmetic play a way more vital position than prior to now. Laptop consultants, mathematicians, and physicists have to respect the hard-earned expertise of conventional biologists. There isn’t any manner the tub mechanism could possibly be carried out efficiently, if doable, with out the experience of molecular biologists, cell biologists, natural chemists, and others aware of the detailed construction and performance of the chromosomes and cells within the human physique. The identical might be mentioned of different doable techniques of good medication and algorithms that might be able to selectively kill most cancers cells.

So too, biologists have to respect the experience of laptop consultants, mathematicians, and physicists. Profitable mathematical modeling is often a tedious, time consuming course of taking months or years, sometimes longer than many fast few week biology experiments. Even a Nobel Prize in molecular biology or different spectacular credentials doesn’t make one an knowledgeable in mathematical modeling or different methods that can be wanted to use arithmetic and computer systems efficiently to most cancers and different issues. Administration degree points comparable to technical feasibility, scope, issue, and complicated technical points will come up in a collaboration between biologists and mathematicians. These will have to be mentioned freely in an grownup method to succeed.

There are various urgent issues on this planet right this moment like most cancers. As present headlines attest, we’re doing a poor job fixing many of those issues. For essentially the most half, the big energy of right this moment’s computer systems has not been utilized efficiently to those issues. In some instances, there was no try. In different instances, the favored approaches have failed regardless of many years of effort and genuinely new or just unpopular concepts needs to be tried. The Struggle on Most cancers might be an instance of the latter case.

Steve Jobs can be remembered for entertaining devices just like the iPad, the iPhone, and the Macintosh. What an accomplishment it will be if these devices went on to efficiently remedy main issues just like the most cancers that felled their creator.

© 2011 John F. McGowan
In regards to the Creator
John F. McGowan, Ph.D. solves issues by growing advanced algorithms that embody superior mathematical and logical ideas, together with video compression and speech recognition applied sciences. He has intensive expertise growing software program in C, C++, Visible Fundamental, Mathematica, MATLAB, and lots of different programming languages. He’s most likely finest recognized for his AVI Overview, an Web FAQ (Steadily Requested Questions) on the Microsoft AVI (Audio Video Interleave) file format. He has labored as a contractor at NASA Ames Analysis Middle concerned within the analysis and growth of picture and video processing algorithms and know-how. He has printed articles on the origin and evolution of life, the exploration of Mars (anticipating the invention of methane on Mars), and low-cost entry to area. He has a Ph.D. in physics from the College of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and a B.S. in physics from the California Institute of Expertise (Caltech). He might be reached at [email protected].



English: Bacteriophage P2 utilizing Transmission Electron Microscope
Creator: Mostafa Fatehi
This file is licensed underneath the Inventive Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported license.

An artist’s rendering of a T4 bacteriophage.
Supply Self-modeled in Blender.
Creator: Mysid
This file is within the public area